PULSCAR ANALYSIS - P2195 AND THE LEAN-SENSOR COMPLAINTS: THE SORTING RULES PulsCar analysis of NHTSA public data, November 2026. License: CC BY 4.0 # Sorting rules — P2195 complaints (stuck-lean upstream oxygen / air-fuel sensor, and lean-mixture complaints) Question the article asks: when an owner reports a "lean" fault, an upstream (front) oxygen or air-fuel sensor fault, or P2195-P2198, what did the owner say was found or done: a stuck/bad sensor, or a really lean mixture, or something else? ## RELEVANCE (field `rel`) Y = the narrative describes, for the owner's own car, a lean-mixture fault or warning, a P2195/P2196/P2197/P2198 code, or a fault/warning/repair of the front (upstream, sensor 1, air-fuel ratio, A/F) oxygen sensor. N = anything else: lean wording that is not about the mixture (e.g. "lean" a car leaning, a lean-burn marketing remark), a rear (downstream, sensor 2) sensor only, an oxygen sensor mentioned only in a list of unrelated parts, an NHTSA staff note without a car fault, other people's cars, motorcycles, tractors, motorhomes. When the owner says only "oxygen sensor" with no position, it is Y if a fault/warning/repair is described. ## CATEGORY (what the owner says was found or done; the LATEST, most specific answer in the text wins) S = the front sensor itself was replaced, or a shop/dealer said the sensor was bad (without naming another cause) L = a really lean mixture cause was named: air leak, vacuum/intake/PCV leak, MAF/airflow, fuel pump/pressure/injector/fuel quality W = a wire, connector, fuse, harness, water/fluid on the harness or sensor F = software update/reprogramming, recall, service bulletin, campaign, or warranty extension was the stated answer X = exhaust leak or catalytic converter named as the cause E = engine mechanical cause named (misfire, oil/coolant consumption, carbon, internal failure) U = no diagnosis or repair stated, or "nothing found", or still unrepaired Precedence when several apply: F > W > L > X > E > S > U (a stated documented program beats a part; a part that did not cure and nothing else named stays S with flag RET). ## FLAGS (1 = yes, 0 = no) CODE = the narrative itself prints P2195, P2196, P2197 or P2198 (any spelling: PO, space, suffix 00, bare 2195 after the word code/DTC) FRONT = the narrative says the upstream/front/sensor 1/air-fuel/A-F sensor (not just "oxygen sensor") STALL = the narrative says the engine stalled, shut off, hesitated badly, lost power or went into limp/reduced power RET = the owner says the problem returned or the first repair did not cure it ## OUTPUT One line per complaint, CSV with header: odino,rel,category,CODE,FRONT,STALL,RET,note note = at most 12 words, no commas. If rel is N use category U and flags 0 unless CODE applies. Rules written before sorting were fingerprinted (SHA-256, written 2026-11-19T17:13:18Z): eeebfe34304f8d0c46e8134f3c9094338fb117c1d20ce2d79093cfa9d6794a8a First search (what found the 172 complaints): a narrative that prints P2195, P2196, P2197 or P2198 in any spelling (letter O for zero, a space, the suffix 00, or the bare number after 'code', 'DTC' or 'error'); or that uses the words air-fuel (ratio) sensor, A/F sensor, AFR sensor or wide-band sensor; or that uses 'stuck lean', 'too lean', 'running lean', 'runs lean', 'lean condition', 'lean code', 'lean fault', 'lean bank', 'lean mixture' or 'lean fuel' together with sensor, oxygen, code, check engine or MIL wording. Second search (2 complaints added): bare numbers 2196 and the words 'Biased/Stuck Rich - Bank 1, Sensor 1' that the first search missed. Lean or fuel-trim wording without sensor, code or check-engine wording was not added: the P0171 and P0174 pages own it. Rules applied when the two sortings disagreed (15 complaints) and to the flags: R1 a recall/update mentioned as history that did not stop the fault is not category F. R2 parts replaced with no cause named: S (if the front/O2/A-F sensor was among them), flag RET. R3 a scan-tool code description pasted by the owner without a stated cause: U; an owner-stated cause wins. R4 owner theory of the cause counts as the stated cause (category of that cause); engine replaced/failed with no lean cause named: U. R5 rich-only or soot complaints with no sensor fault described: N. A guess ('like too rich or lean') is N. R6 STALL and RET flags are 1 only when both sorters set them (conservative; counts are 'at least'). R7 FRONT: 1 only when both set it.