P0420 statistics: what 302 federal complaints and 143 bulletins show

Short answer. In PulsCar's count of the NHTSA complaint file, 302 owner complaints name code P0420, and 232 of them mention the catalytic converter. The typical car is about 7 model years old, and the median stated mileage is about 109,000 miles. Only 18 of the 98 complaints that state a mileage fall inside the federal 8-year, 80,000-mile emissions warranty.

This page is the short, citable version of our full P0420 guide, which explains what the code means, what to check before buying a converter and what each fix costs. The numbers below come from public NHTSA data, counted by PulsCar, and the underlying counts are published as open CSV files under CC BY 4.0, so anyone can check or reuse them.

Key numbers

Data: NHTSA owner complaints received 1 January 2015 to 8 September 2026, pulled 14 September 2026.

MeasureValue
Unique NHTSA owner reports searched777,040
Complaints naming P0420302 (313 if the typo "P420" is allowed)
Of those, mentioning the catalytic converter232 (77%)
Mentioning a misfire or a P030X code36
Mentioning an oxygen or air-fuel sensor35
Mentioning an exhaust leak5
Median age of the car when the report was received7 model years
Complaints from cars 8 or more model years old142 of 302 (47%)
Complaints that state a mileage98
Median stated mileageabout 109,000 miles
Inside both 8 years and 80,000 miles (of those 98)18
Complaints describing a refused warranty claim31
Complaints naming P0430 (bank 2)106, of which 42 are Honda Pilots
Manufacturer bulletins naming P0420 (2015 to August 2026)143, from 12 manufacturer groups
Share of those bulletins that are software updatesat least 60%

Five findings, one sentence each

  1. Owners describe a converter, but the converter is not always the cause. 77% of P0420 complaints mention the converter, yet 36 also mention a misfire, 35 a sensor and 5 an exhaust leak, any of which can set the code first.
  2. Most of these cars are out of warranty. Only 18 of 98 complaints with a stated mileage were inside both the 8-year and the 80,000-mile limit.
  3. Software fixes are common. At least 60% of the 143 manufacturer bulletins naming P0420 are software or reprogramming updates, not new hardware.
  4. One model dominates the file. The Kia Soul accounts for 84 of the 302 complaints, 73 of them on 2012 to 2016 cars, and 30 cite recall 19V-120 or campaign SC176. Check the Kia Soul guide and your VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls before paying for a converter.
  5. Complaints are rising. Reports naming P0420 went from 30 in 2019 to 57 in 2026 (through 8 September), and 45 in 2025. Owners file more complaints for many reasons, so this shows more reports, not more failures.

Bank 2: P0430

106 complaints name P0430, the same fault on the other cylinder bank, and 42 of them are Honda Pilots, mostly 2016, 2017 and 2019 models. Twenty-four complaints name both P0420 and P0430.

Where the 302 reports sit on the warranty clock

Age of the car at the reportComplaints
0 to 3 years15
4 to 7 years145
8 to 11 years111
12 years or more31
Odometer at the report (98 complaints that state one)Complaints
Under 80,000 miles24
80,000 to 119,99937
120,000 to 159,99925
160,000 and over12

Age is the model year subtracted from the year the report was received, so it is approximate. A complaint is an owner's report, and an owner whose converter was replaced free rarely files one: the table shows who complains, not how many converters fail.

Recalls and campaigns that can change the bill

CampaignVehicles
NHTSA 19V-120 and Kia SC1762012 to 2016 Kia Soul 1.6 GDI
Ford emission recall 24E042022 to 2023 F-150 hybrid

Run the VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls before accepting a converter quote. The Check Engine Code Index lists the bulletins and the method behind the count of 143.

Typical repair costs in the US, 2026

RepairTypical range
Diagnostic fee$80 to $150 independent, $120 to $200 dealer
Exhaust leak ahead of the sensor$100 to $400
Misfire repair (plugs or a coil)$150 to $400
Downstream oxygen sensor$200 to $400 installed
Universal weld-in converter$200 to $600
Direct-fit aftermarket converter$700 to $1,600
OEM converter$1,500 to $2,500 independent, up to $4,500 dealer

These are estimates from our P0420 guide. The quote depends on the car, the region and the shop.

Method and data

PulsCar searched every vehicle complaint added to NHTSA's public complaint files between 1 January 2015 and 8 September 2026, de-duplicated by report number (777,040 unique reports), for the exact string "P0420" and the common typo "P420", ignoring case. Bulletins are counted from the manufacturer service bulletins received by NHTSA from 2015 to August 2026. A complaint mentioning a part does not prove that part was at fault.

Open files (CC BY 4.0):

How to cite

PulsCar (2026). P0420 in the NHTSA complaint file: 302 complaints, 143 bulletins. https://www.pulscar.io/blog/p0420-statistics. Data under CC BY 4.0.